The presentation and tin note are top-notch, with all the coins perfectly intact. The flavor is rich and refined, offering a delightful experience from the top of the bowl, through the mid-bowl, all the way to the end. I’ve already bought six tins and plan to get more right away. The bowl burns cleanly, leaving behind white ash—and the taste is absolutely delicious! I did a back-to-back comparison between Charatan and Peterson DeLuxe Navy Rolls. Both are excellent, but I’d give Charatan a slight edge, about half a star better. That said, I smoke a lot of Peterson as well, so just being honest from my subjective point of view. Enjoy it!