How to Tell If a Cigar Is Good Quality

Cigars have long been a symbol of celebration and relaxation — a moment to slow down, reflect, or simply enjoy good company. But not all cigars are made equal. They come in a wide range of flavors, strengths, wrappers, and sizes, and learning how to recognize a well-made cigar can make all the difference in your experience. Whether you’re new to cigars or looking to refine your palate, here’s what to pay attention to.

Understanding a Cigar’s Body

When people talk about a cigar’s “body,” they’re referring to its strength and intensity. It’s what gives a cigar its overall character.

• Mild-bodied cigars are smooth, lighter on the palate, and often preferred by beginners.

• Medium-bodied cigars balance richness and smoothness.

• Full-bodied cigars deliver stronger flavors and are usually favored by experienced smokers.

If a cigar feels overwhelming or harsh, it’s probably too strong for you at the moment. Work your way up gradually — part of the fun is discovering which strength best matches your taste.

Size, Shape, and Gauge

Cigars come in all shapes and sizes — and that affects not just how they look, but how they smoke. A larger ring gauge (the cigar’s diameter, measured in 64ths of an inch) typically allows for a cooler, slower burn, while thinner cigars burn a little faster and hotter.
For example, a cigar with a 50-ring gauge is about 50/64 of an inch thick. Length also plays a role: longer cigars give you a longer smoke, while shorter ones are ideal for a quick session.

The shape — whether it’s a classic parejo (straight-sided) or a tapered torpedo — adds to both the draw and the overall feel in hand.

How to Choose a Good Cigar

If you’re just starting out, begin with something mild and approachable. Take a close look at the wrapper — the color can tell you a lot. Lighter wrappers usually mean a milder flavor, while darker ones often pack more intensity.

Give it a gentle squeeze; a good cigar should be firm but slightly springy. If it feels dry, brittle, or makes a cracking sound, it’s likely past its prime. Always store cigars in a humidor to maintain proper humidity and freshness.

And finally, trust your nose — if the pre-light aroma draws you in, chances are it’ll taste just as good.

Recommended Cigars to Explore

Villiger La Vencedora
A rich yet balanced handmade cigar from Nicaragua, offering notes of wood, pepper, and molasses. It starts smooth, builds flavor gradually, and pairs beautifully with Gentleman Jack Whiskey. Perfect for beginners who want a taste of a classic, medium-bodied cigar without overwhelming strength.

Villiger La Flor de Ynclan
Crafted in the Dominican Republic, this cigar blends hints of cedar, spice, and dried fruit. Its Torpedo shape enhances the aroma and flavor progression. Medium-bodied with a subtle sweetness, it’s a great all-around choice that pairs nicely with Caribbean-style rum.

Villiger 1888
Elegant and complex, this Dominican-made cigar opens with floral and cedar notes, followed by pepper, caramel, and coffee. Its smooth draw and medium-to-full body make it a refined choice for more seasoned smokers. Try it with coffee, port, or dark rum for a perfect match.

Final Thoughts

As you explore different cigars, you’ll start to notice what appeals most to your senses — maybe it’s a certain aroma, a creamy texture, or a lingering spice. Developing your palate takes time, but that’s part of the joy. Wherever you are and whatever the occasion, there’s always a good cigar waiting to be enjoyed.